To print this article, all you need is to be registered or login on Mondaq.com.
The president of the Canadian Hernia Society, Dr. John Morrison,
has been spreading word of an “epidemic” of mesh-related
complications he has been witnessing for the past few years.
“…And unfortunately, there’s no end in sight,” he
says. “It’s going to get worse because almost all hernias
are now repaired with mesh.”
But just how bad is this epidemic, and how much worse will it
get? There is a significant debate within the medical community
about how to measure the relative success or failures of surgical
In this blog post I examine some ways medical practitioners
calculate the failure rates of hernia mesh, explain how some of
these rates tend to worsen over time, and offer some information
about what people experiencing painful complications can do.
The Gold Standard
How do you measure success when it comes to the 100,000 hernia
surgeries performed in Canada every year? Prior to the
introduction of modern suturing techniques and surgical mesh, a
staggering number of hernias (10-30%) would return following an
operation. Subsequent operations generally
had much less chance of success.
The introduction of tension-free surgical mesh dramatically
reduced the rate of recurrence and greatly increased the popularity
of mesh among physicians and surgeons. According to Dr. Morrison,
“The gold standard of hernia repair is the recurrence rate.
People measure the success of hernia surgeries by how many came
Understandably, no one wants a hernia to return following an
operation; by this measure – recurrence rates for
laparoscopic mesh surgeries range from about 0.5% to 4% – the
trend towards using surgical mesh was a resounding success.
However, those numbers don’t tell the full story. And
it’s a story mainstream news media, including the
renowned investigative journalists at CTV’s W5, are beginning
By The Numbers: Hernia Recurrence
Although recurrence is one of the possible complications from
surgery, it is certainly not the only one. Other reported
complications from defective hernia mesh include bowel obstruction,
fistulas, adhesions, and most commonly infections and chronic pain
(pain lasting longer than three months).
Medical practitioners disagree about the true rate of all
complications, including recurrence, following hernia mesh surgery.
Some doctors, such as Dr. David Urbach,
surgeon‐in‐chief at Toronto’s Women’s College
Hospital, have said they believe complications are exceedingly
rare; only up to 2% of patients will experience them.
Others, such as Dr. Morrison, suggest the generally accepted rate
of complications, including chronic pain, ranges between 10-15%.
Still other American studies have pegged the rate as high as 43%,
and suggest a rate of about 20% is most accurate.
Why the difference in numbers? In some cases,
the studies or individual reporting by doctors use different
definitions of pain. In other cases, the studies have not tracked
the long-term consequences of defective mesh.
Dr. Vladimir Iakovlev, Director of Cytopathology at
Toronto’s St. Michael’s Hospital, states that Canadian
doctors “probably don’t know exact rates of complications
at this stage. Some complications occur [after] four or five years
and sometimes [he gets] a mesh explant 10 years after implantation.
So a study needs to follow patients for at least 10 years or so to
actually catch that true complication rate.”
Dr. Morrison explains that hernia complications involving mesh
can happen at any time. Infection, one of the most common
complications, “can happen on Day 1 or Day 1,001,” due to
foreign body reactions.
Defective Hernia Mesh Removal: Gone But Not Forgotten
While any surgery comes with the risk of complications, the
medical literature is increasingly suggesting hernia repairs using
defective mesh products are causing many problems over the
Declining recurrence rates might mean more hernias are gone for
good, but the patients who experience complications weeks, months,
or years later will not soon forget the operation that implanted
the defective mesh in their bodies.
In fact, as W5 reports, a growing number of mesh patients are
desperately searching for surgeons, such as Dr. Morrison, who will
perform surgery to remove, not just repair, the defective mesh in
hopes it will fix the problems they are experiencing.
“They feel that nobody will listen to them.,” Dr.
Morrison says of patients experiencing life-altering pain.
“And that is the most striking feature of all, that they are
getting passed from one professional to another to another,”
We Will Listen To You
There may be disagreements about hernia mesh failure rates and
conflicting numbers. But, ultimately, victims of defective hernia
mesh who are suffering serious complications are not just a number
or a statistic; they are human beings whose lives have been
severely impacted by a defective medical product.
If you or a loved one has required revision surgery or your
physician has recommended this option, you may meet the threshold
to be eligible for legal action against the manufacturers of the
defective product. An experienced hernia mesh lawyer can listen to
your story and inform you about your ability to seek damages for
the pain and suffering this defective product has caused.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.
POPULAR ARTICLES ON: Litigation, Mediation & Arbitration from Canada